I have one of these. Works really good for my horse that gets really tender footed/sore if she throws a shoe. Can stay on during turn out,and stays in well. I always take it off in the evening to clean it out, and will put it back on. If I’m going to be out at the horse barn for a while I’ll leave it off until I leave just to let the hoof breath some. You can also get pads to go inside to give extra comfort.