My sister’s TB overreaches as well and in general rips off her front shoes in about a week. She gets turned out with no turns and then plain Davis bell boots over those. Sometimes my sister duct tapes too just for an extra layer. I have heard the Davis bell boots rub pretty bad. I prefer to use Classic Equine DyNo turn boots. They are a snug fit, don’t rub that I’ve seen and dirt doesn’t travel up the boot. Aren’t as easy to hose off as the rubber Davis, but oh well.
A lot of the horses I have known who wear bell boots almost all the time are TBs, I think it must be a breed thing.