I wear a 5 1/2 and my teenage daughter has a 5. Both have narrow feet and tall think legs. In the less expensive arena like you, I can make the Ariat tall slims work. They are however too short to really show in and don’t come thin enough from my daughter. The only brand we have found, outside of customs that works is the Parlanti. Their non-custom boots come in a huge range of feet, height, and calf options. Only issue is price. I think we still paid over $1,000 for stock boots.