Cosequin ASU vs. Smartflex

This topic contains 5 replies, has 5 voices, and was last updated by  cemn0312 4 years, 3 months ago.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Leslie Original Poster Leslie
    Topics Started: 1Replies Posted: 44

    Has anyone tried both (not at the same time)? If so at what dosages and which Smartflex? Which did you find worked better?

    (Really looking for a comparison between the two, not reviews on them individually – Smartpak’s already got that covered 🙂 )

    Anyone use it as a preventative?

    • This topic was modified 4 years, 3 months ago by Leslie Leslie.

    www.createdbyleslie.com - handmade custom wood-burned brushes, stall signs, & portraits, etched glasses, and custom stuffed ponies

    Odie4Me Odie4Me
    Topics Started: 0Replies Posted: 13

    I have used both on two different horses. My WB is on CosequinASU and my Q/A is on SmartFlex. My WB did not do well on SmartFlex, but is very comfortable on CosequinASU. My 18 year old Q/A is very sound on SmartFlex and I saw no difference when he was on CosequinASU. So, try the SmartFlex first, if after a month no difference, go with CosequinASU. I also tried the CosequinSP, but didn’t like it as much as ASU. There is something about the ASU that really seems to help with joint issues. My WB has great hocks and he is 12 now.
    Good Luck. Hope this helps.

    Leslie Original Poster Leslie
    Topics Started: 1Replies Posted: 44

    Thanks. I use the Cosequin ASU now but was wondering if I’d be able to switch since it’s so expensive. But I’ll just keep with it if it seems to be better.

    www.createdbyleslie.com - handmade custom wood-burned brushes, stall signs, & portraits, etched glasses, and custom stuffed ponies

    Janyse
    Topics Started: 3Replies Posted: 16

    I hvae used Smartflex Senior Pellets and Cosequin ASU Plus and have found a big difference in the results.
    My 26 year old Paint was started on Smartflex Senior back in 2011 and I saw a slight improvement in his right leg stiffness. My veterenarian recommended a gram of Bute before each ride while on SmartFlex Sr. My farrier also asked that I give him the same dose of bute before each shoeing.
    I switched him to Cosequin ASU Plus because of the Hyaluronic acid it contains.After a few of months, I noticed big difference. I no longer need to give him bute before rides or shoeings.
    Good luck!

    Enjoy your ride,
    Janyse

    TWH Girl TWH Girl
    Topics Started: 2Replies Posted: 31

    I would be curious to hear as well. 24 yr old is on Smartflex Sr and 11 yr old just started on Cosequin asu about a week ago. Older one quit eating his pellets so i changed to the powder. Now that Cosequin sp is not available, really wish they would offer the Cosequin with msm as an option in between the original and the asu versions. I will post how my guy is doing on the asu…it’s mostly a preventative, but lately i feel like he may have a weak right stifle. We shall see…

    cemn0312
    Topics Started: 0Replies Posted: 1

    I had my 18 yr. gelding on Smartflex Sr. pellets (he’s always had minor stifle weakness), which he did very well on. I was forced to switch him to Cosequin ASU only because he decided to stop eating the Smartflex – although he is doing very well on that as well. I can’t honestly say I’ve noticed a huge difference between the two – what I do notice is a positive difference between the Cosequin ASU and the old school Cosequin (which is great in its own right!). Maybe I’ll notice more of a difference come winter – but for now I’d say either is pretty darn good!

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.